
Many baseball players, coaches and fans are convinced that bats made of aluminum or other metals outperform traditional wooden bats, sending balls screaming out of the park.
But do these hi-tech bats work so well that they pose a health hazard, crushing balls with such force that they can become lethal projectiles?
New York City believes so. Its City Council last month passed a ban against bats made from metal for use in high school games, with enough votes to defeat a veto by Mayor Michael Bloomberg.
Other governments, large and small, across the country are considering similar measures during April, National Youth Sports Safety Month.
“The kids don’t have a second to react to those balls anymore,” said Debbie Patch, of Miles City, Mont., who testified before the New York City Council about the death of her 18-year-old son, Brandon, a pitcher who was struck in the head by a ball hit by a metal bat. “The companies promote it that way. They promote it as, ‘Choose your weapon,’ and that’s what they are.”
But, the co-author of one of the studies cited to argue the deadly potential of metal bats says New York City may have acted in haste.
“To my knowledge, there are no published, peer-reviewed articles that show there is an increased incidence of injury from the use of aluminum bats,” said Richard M. Greenwald, executive director of the National Institute for Sports Science and Safety, and an adjunct associate professor of engineering at Dartmouth College.
More…